Integrated Living Options

Permanent Injunction

  • 37 The Commonwealth will work to achieve a goal of a 2% annual increase in the percentage of individuals on the DD waiver receiving day services in the most integrated settings. To achieve that goal, the Commonwealth will take the following action:
    1.  Within one month of the date of this Order, DBHDS’s Community Life Engagement Advisory Committee will implement a work plan that includes measurable goals, specific support activities, and timelines for implementation and that is focused on: defining meaningful community involvement; developing training and educational materials to enhance meaningful community involvement for individuals and families, providers, and case managers; and assessing community involvement data.
    2.  If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal as reported in its status update of December 1, 2024, and has not conducted a rate study meeting the requirements of Paragraph 59 in the preceding two years, the Commonwealth will initiate a rate study of Community Engagement, Workplace Assistance, and Community Coaching by January 1, 2025. The rate study shall be completed in time to be considered during the 2026 legislative session. If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal as reported in its status update of December 1, 2028, and has not conducted a second rate study meeting the requirements of Paragraph 59, the Commonwealth will initiate a second rate study of Community Engagement, Workplace Assistance, and Community Coaching by January 1, 2029. The rate study shall be completed in time to be considered during the 2030 legislative session. Any rate study required by this paragraph shall be conducted in accordance with Paragraph 59. This paragraph shall not be construed to require the Commonwealth to conduct more than two rate studies.
    3.  If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal within two years of the date of this Order after taking the actions in Paragraph 37(a), DBHDS will also conduct a root cause analysis and determine whether a QII is warranted to address identified issues. A root cause analysis and consideration of QII will not be required if the percentage of individuals in the integrated day services reported above is 65% of the total number of the people receiving any day service.

  • 38. The Commonwealth will work to achieve a goal that 70% of individuals on the DD waiver and children with DD receiving EPSDT with private duty nursing identified in their ISP or prescribed under EPSDT receive 80% of the hours identified as needed on the CMS485 or DMAS62 forms. To achieve that goal, the Commonwealth will take the following actions.
    1.  Semi-annually, on May 15 and November 15 of each year, DBHDS will continue to report data on utilization of nursing services and the work of the DBHDS Nursing Workgroup, except if the Independent Reviewer is monitoring the Commonwealth’s compliance under Section VIII, DBHDS will report on April 15 and October 15 of each year.
    2.  By September 30, 2024, DBHDS will update the ISP to allow for collection of nursing needs data identified by the Risk Awareness Tool.
    3.  DBHDS will continue to implement an IMNR that will assess if individuals have unmet nursing or other medical needs and will work with families, providers, and case managers to take steps to resolve identified unmet needs. Semi-annually, on April 15 and October 15 of each year, DBHDS will report on the IMNR process, including the types of unmet needs identified and efforts taken to resolve them.
    4.  Within six months of the date of this Order, in consultation with the five DBHDS Registered Nurse Care Consultants, the Commonwealth will:
      1. i. Identify which CSB catchment areas in each Region have the highest nursing shortages for this target population based on objective criteria and data, including how many individuals with private duty nursing receive 80% of their hours;
      2. ii. Identify the top three barriers to individuals accessing nursing services in each region based on objective data, including stakeholder data and state and national workforce data and research; 
      3. iii. Develop a work plan to resolve those barriers that includes measurable goals, specific support activities, and timelines for implementation; and
      4. iv. Include the barriers and efforts to resolve them, as well as the factual basis for those barriers and efforts, and results achieved in the semiannual nursing report that is posted in the Library.
    5. If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal as reported in its status update of December 1, 2024, or the semi-annual report of the Independent Reviewer, if there is one, and has not conducted a rate study meeting the requirements of Paragraph 59 in the preceding two years, the Commonwealth will initiate a rate study of Private Duty Nursing by January 1, 2025. The rate study shall be completed in time to be considered during the 2026 legislative session. If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal as reported in its status update of December 1, 2028, and has not conducted a second rate study meeting the requirements of Paragraph 59, the Commonwealth will initiate a second rate study of Private Duty Nursing by January 1, 2029. The rate study shall be completed in time to be considered at the 2030 legislative session. Any rate study required by this paragraph shall be conducted in accordance with Paragraph 59. This paragraph shall not be construed to require the Commonwealth to conduct more than two rate studies.
    6. If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal within two years of the date of this Order after taking the actions in Paragraphs 38(a) through 38(d), DBHDS also will conduct a root cause analysis and determine whether a QII is warranted to address identified issues. DBHDS will continue this quality improvement process until the goal is achieved and sustained for one year.

  • 39. The Commonwealth will work to achieve a goal that 70% of individuals on the DD waiver and children with DD receiving EPSDT with skilled nursing identified in their ISPs or prescribed under EPSDT will have their skilled nursing needs met 80% of the time. To achieve that goal, the Commonwealth will take the following actions:
    1.  Semi-annually, on May 15 and November 15 of each year, DBHDS will continue to report data on utilization of nursing services and the work of the DBHDS Nursing Workgroup, except if the Independent Reviewer is monitoring the Commonwealth’s compliance under Section VIII, DBHDS will report on April 15 and October 15 of each year.
    2.  As part of the IMNR Process, DBHDS will assess if individuals have unmet nursing or other medical needs and will work with families, providers, and case managers to take steps to resolve identified unmet needs. Semi-annually, on April 15 and October 15 of each year, DBHDS will report on the IMNR process, including the types of unmet needs identified, efforts taken to resolve them, and results achieved.
    3.  Skilled Nursing Review. Beginning within three months of the date of this Order, for individuals with a skilled nursing need identified in the Waiver Management System, DBHDS will begin to conduct on-site IMNR reviews as set forth in this paragraph. DBHDS will conduct the on-site IMNR reviews of a randomized sample of 10% of individuals annually (split between two six-month reviews) to determine if individuals’ skilled nursing services needs are being met. In selecting individuals during each six-month review period to review, DBHDS shall include in the sample only individuals who were authorized to receive the service at least three months earlier, to ensure sufficient time for the sampled individuals to have received the service.
    4.  If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal as reported in its December 1, 2024 status update, or the semi-annual report of the Independent Reviewer, if there is one, and has not conducted a rate study meeting the requirements of Paragraph 59 in the preceding two years, the Commonwealth will initiate a rate study of Skilled Nursing by January 1, 2025. The rate study shall be completed in time to be considered during the 2026 legislative session. If the Commonwealth has not achieved the goal as reported in its December 1, 2028 status update, and has not conducted a second rate study meeting the requirements of Paragraph 59, the Commonwealth will initiate a second rate study of Skilled Nursing by January 1, 2029. The rate study shall be completed in time to be considered at the 2030 legislative session. Any rate study required by this paragraph shall be conducted in accordance with Paragraph 59. This paragraph shall not be construed to require the Commonwealth to conduct more than two rate studies.
    5. If the Commonwealth does not achieve the goal within two years of the date of this Order after taking the actions in Paragraphs 39(a) through 39(c), DBHDS will also conduct a root cause analysis and implement a QII as determined appropriate by DBHDS. DBHDS will continue this quality improvement process until the goal is achieved and sustained for one year.

Settlement Agreement

The Commonwealth shall serve individuals in the target population in the most integrated setting consistent with their informed choice and needs.


About Integrated Living Options

The Commonwealth is committed to serving individuals with development disabilities in the most integrated settings appropriate to their needs and consistent with their informed choice. The state’s capacity to serve individuals with development disabilities across Virginia in integrated community based settings continues to grow.  The DD waivers as redesigned in 2016 increase the services options available to support individuals to live in more integrated settings.  The redesign also realigned the waivers funding structures to provide incentives to provider agencies that serve individual in integrated residential settings.

The Settlement Agreement uses the benchmark of four beds or less as an indicator of an integrated residential setting.  Since the signing of the Agreement, Medicaid has issued final rules with respect to integrated settings for residential service types that must be met to receive Home and Community Based (Waiver) funding.   The reports provided track both the movement of the DD Waiver population as they move to more integrated residential settings and the capacity of the service system to provide integrated residential options.

The other aspect of Integrated Community Living Options is the focus Virginia is placing on individuals who reside in Intermediate Care Facilities for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities (ICFs/IID) and children in nursing homes.  DBHDS has focused efforts to ensure that individuals seeking placements in these community institutional settings are informed about options in community.  In addition there are dedicated staff working with individuals already in these settings, their families, Community Service Boards and other community resources to facilitate discharges to integrated community based services. 

Trend Data

Compliance Indicator 18.9 Language:

DBHDS established a baseline annual utilization rate for private duty (65%) and skilled nursing services (62%) in the DD Waivers as of June 30, 2018 for FY 2018. The utilization rate is defined by whether the hours for the service are identified as a need in an individual’s ISP and then whether the hours are delivered. Data will be tracked separately for EPSDT and waiver funded nursing. Seventy percent of individuals who have these services identified in their ISP (or, for children under 21 years old, have prescribed nursing because of EPSDT) must have these services delivered within 30 days, and at the number of hours identified in their ISP, eighty percent of the time.

Compliance Indicator 29.20 Language:

The Commonwealth shall meet the following: a. At least 86% of the people supported in residential settings will receive an annual physical exam, including review of preventive screenings, and at least 86% of individuals who have coverage for dental services will receive an annual dental exam.

Authorizing Authority

Americans with Disabilities Act, 42 U.S.C. § 12101 et seq.

US Supreme Court Olmstead Decision

Delegation

Processes, Protocols and Standards

Case Management Manual

Guidelines, Charters, Plans, Other

Instruments and Tools

Training Materials